Immigration, sled dogs and slot machines

Print Article

Week 7 of the 2017 legislative session has been the busiest yet. Floor sessions have been starting earlier than usual in order to have enough time to vote on all the bills and conduct our regular business. We have voted on bills ranging from forgone taxes in taxing districts, audits of the soil and water conservation districts, public records exemptions, wine and construction management licenses, fingerprinting for certain professions, elections, and even micromanagement of how names on real estate signs are displayed.

My State Affairs Committee has been meeting daily for a full two hours each morning. Many interesting topics pass through this committee. It has been very busy and often filled with heated debate. This week, a new bill was introduced related to immigration laws and withholding tax revenues from cities that fail to comply. The room was packed for that debate. Tribal gaming and slot machine definitions have also dominated the committee’s time the last few weeks.

There was more than four hours of testimony for and against a gambling bill related to slot machines. Currently there are several types of machines used by the state lottery and by the various tribal casinos that may be questionable with respect to the law. Vagueness in the current language makes it hard to check if the machines in casinos are constitutional or not.

This is why it is always imperative that legislators insure the language of every bill is as clear and concise as possible to avoid these legal pitfalls. It is also critical that citizens make their voices heard at committee hearings.

I sponsored HB 151 which passed through the State Affairs Committee and onto the House floor. This bill will assure that sled dog racing will remain legal in Idaho despite the ban on dog racing. Many may not know, but Idaho holds three well-known sled dog races every year including the American Dog Derby in Ashton, which is longest continuously run race in America (100 years.). This bill, if passed by the Senate, will protect this long-standing tradition in Idaho for all to enjoy and participate.

As of Friday morning, the Senate has printed 114 bills and the House has printed 202 along with 37 memorials and resolutions. Most of these bills, and the majority of the bills that are allowed to be heard in committees, have been written by government agencies, the executive branch or special interest groups. Unfortunately, very few bills have been citizen-initiated through their legislators or by the legislators themselves.

Most of the liberty bills (bills limiting government growth) are still languishing locked in committee chairmen’s drawers. Some chairmen are unwilling to put these bills on the agendas. Legislators sponsoring these bills are given a variety of vague reasons why their voices and the voices of their citizens are being silenced, but the real reason is these bills challenge the power of top-down centralized government. I encourage all citizens to contact each chairman of every committee and share any concerns they may have with stalled bills.

Committees are composed of representatives from all across the state. A chairman comes from only one district. We, the people, are supposed to have a representative government here in Idaho, but the “process” has devolved into numerous committee chairmen either thinking they are the head of a fiefdom with absolute veto power or they perceive protecting their political careers is more important than the citizens they represent.

A few of the bills sitting in various chairman’s drawers include:

• A bill to repeal the SBAC test

• A bill to make Common Core optional for schools.

• A bill to repeal Obamacare (Affordable Care Act).

• An income tax cut (held in Senate committee)

• The castle doctrine gun bill

• A bill to allow bills with a certain amount of sponsors to be heard by the committee (how ironic)

You can view all the House bills at

Constitution — t change or not to change?

An Article V Convention bill was introduced in the State Affairs Committee this week. It includes language on an application of a convention for proposing amendments and addresses criteria for selecting commissioners.

There is also talk of another gas tax increase circulating around the capitol. The gas tax increase will be hard to justify again this year with a $140 million revenue surplus sitting in the state coffers.

Hopefully the citizens will make their voices heard loud and clear on these issues.

The past few weeks have included many luncheons and events as well as a memorial for deceased legislators, and a Lincoln Day presentation. The capitol has been packed with visitors and groups from all over the state. Rep. Raul Labrador, R-Idaho, addressed the House body on Wednesday of this week. The Know Your Government 4-H young adults were in town for a conference and to pass mock legislation. We even had the Lund family visit from North Idaho. It’s nice to see so many interested in what we do.

Rep. Heather Scott represents Bonner and Boundary counties in District 1A. She can be reached online at, or by phone, 208-920-3120.

Print Article

Read More Editorial

Keeping our forests healthy and less prone to wildfire

October 18, 2017 at 6:00 am | Priest River Times Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria have caused total and unprecedented devastation in parts of Texas, Florida, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and the rest of the Caribbean. As Chairman of the Se...


Read More

Dumb electric vehicle agreement gets government in the way

October 11, 2017 at 6:00 am | Priest River Times If electric vehicle manufacturers want mass adoption of their product, including in western states, they should take it upon themselves to get the job done, not depend on government to do it for them...


Read More

Tax reform requires a comprehensive approach

October 04, 2017 at 6:00 am | Priest River Times Serious work on federal tax reform is encouraging, as the best way to strengthen families, support small business growth and job creation and boost our national economy is to enact pro-growth compreh...


Read More

The true facts about county’s road budget

September 20, 2017 at 6:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee Cuts in Road and Bridge are not being used to accommodate other departments. All departments took a cut as the trajectory of our spending over the last 8 or so years was unsustainable. Every single d...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 448-2431
P.O. Box 159
310 Church Street
Sandpoint Idaho 83864

©2017 Priest River Times Terms of Use Privacy Policy